Salvatore's Cakes & pastries - Tottenham, Ontario

Mr. G.

I have known Salvatore when he was working in Toronto 30+ yrs ago.i ordered so many full slabs of cakes for the office and family birthdays and always turned out perfect. He is a master at his craft and the quality ingredients second to none. All the best to you my friend. You bring so much happiness .

Kendra O.

I can only attest to the food as I have not been in to the store myself! I would give the sweets a 10 star if that was an option! A customer of mine brings in treats from Salvatore's every time he visits. I typically reach for the chocolate cannoli but will try the other ones occasionally and am always left wanting more. Today I tried one of the cheesecakes and let me tell you, it was one of the best I have ever had!! If I could get a full size cheesecake like this for my wedding, I would! So fricking yummy. Keep on making all your phenomenal sweets. One of these days I will make a trip up to get my own variety for my next family / friend function!

Nadia P.

Over the moon with how great my son's 1st birthday cake turned out! Inside and out would happily order from Sal's again! All our guests were so excited for the classic sfoglia and we were not disappointed 😋

Kate C.

Thank you so much for making the cutest and most delicious cake to help celebrate a friend's special news! Really appreciated that you could squeeze in making this cake on such short notice, all while never cutting any corners. You made it so quickly and yet it was absolutely delicious and beautiful. Thanks so so much!

Olivia B.

We have been ordering cakes from Sal's for years and they never disappoint! Today's creation was a Bacio sponge cake. Every flavour we've tried has been better than the next. Highly recommend Sal's for any occasion!

William D. R.

I was in england for a week and got hooked on Flat White coffee ☕️. I went in and asked if they knew how to make it and the said not sure but we can try. They nailed it amazing ☕️ and service.

Junior S.

Hey family,

Here’s my honest review of my visit to Salvatore’s cakes & pastries. I made the visit on Saturday, June 25, 2022 and I wanted to share my personal experience with you below:

Location: 1 star
Serving the Tottenham community you will need to drive a little out of the GTA to reach Salvatores Cakes & Pastries. Previously the owners had served the Vaughan community for many years but have now shifted the focus on this small community. It’s perfect because it offers a service no one in the area offers which is authentic Italian pastries. Parking can be tricky as it’s street parking and it all depends on how busy the town is that day.

Staffing: 1 star
This is a family owned business which means you’ll be getting a personalized experience and may even run into the family of the owners. They are friendly, professional and most of all make you feel like you’re at home. Should you have any dietary restrictions they are very sensitive to it and will always offer an alternative.

Food: 1 star
Authentic, fresh and absolutely delicious Italian pastries, cakes, treats and more. This business was built on the back-bone of its traditional Italian roots. The cakes are in massive demand and you may have to place an order ahead of time as sometimes the store cannot keep up with all the orders. The coffee and drinks are also what you expect from a cafe. Should you have a party in the near future you definitely want to order a custom cake from them.

Service: 1 star
Service is great however during busy times you may have to wait to be served.
As this is a small family business, the food is worth the wait and sometimes high volume can slow down service. Fear not, the owners always acknowledge any guest visiting and will promptly serve you once they are finished with the previous guest.

Wow factor: .5 stars
The wow factor for this business is in the food itself. The cakes and pastries are to die for and the business location itself feels a bit distant from the GTA however, that’s the point. The family moved away from the hustle and bustle to bring their business in a growing neighborhood like Tottenham. The restaurant can use a little TLC but in the age of food speaking before location I’m okay with it. Every summer we’ll make our visit to this location to say hi and stop by for some treats.

All in all, I give Salvatores cakes & pastries a 4.5 out of 5.

Until next time…

Darren B.

I whole heartedly believe that these guys embody what a small business should be.
Friendly staff, with competitive pricing. Besides all that, they remember your name, and give back and are involved with the community.
A lot of lessons can be learned by sitting in this store and enjoying a cannoli and espresso.